Running a Business From Home Without a Permit Could Cost You More Than You Think

For decades, the owners of a ground-floor apartment ran a dental clinic there, but they never got a permit to use the apartment as a business. When their building’s renewal project came along, they refused to join unless they were paid more than a million shekels to set up a new clinic. The Inspector of Land Registration rejected their demand. Their years in business, the money they had invested, and the business-rate arnona they had paid did not replace a proper permit. They also brought no appraisal showing that their apartment was worth more than their neighbours’. The lesson for anyone working from home is simple: if your business isn’t properly permitted, don’t expect the law to protect it when it counts.

In this brief, we look at a ruling by the Inspector of Land Registration in Rehovot. The owners of an apartment that housed a dental clinic asked for more than one million shekels to set up a replacement clinic as a condition of joining a TAMA project. Their fear of losing their livelihood was understandable, but the court rejected their demand. The ruling explains why years in business, money invested, and even expert opinions are not enough when the right evidence and legal basis are missing. It holds important lessons for apartment owners who run a business from a residential apartment without a proper permit.

The Facts

In a residential building in Rehovot, 13 of the 14 apartment owners signed an agreement for a TAMA 38/2 project, under which the existing building would be torn down and a new one built in its place. The owners of a ground-floor apartment refused to join. For decades, a dental clinic had operated there without a permit for non-conforming use (the permit needed to use a residential apartment for another purpose). Like everyone else, they were offered a new apartment, in their case 15 sqm larger than their current one, plus a balcony, a safe room and parking. They argued, however, that the developer had not been chosen through a proper tender; that demolishing the building would shut down the clinic, in which they said they had invested NIS 2 million, and cut off their livelihood; and that their apartment was the largest in the building.

The clinic owners submitted opinions from an engineer and a real estate appraiser. However, these opinions only looked at what it would cost to set up a replacement clinic. They did not compare what the owners were being offered with what the other apartment owners were receiving.

The Clinic Owners’ Arguments

The owners argued that the physical features of their apartment justified a better deal than the one offered, and that they should receive extra compensation to set up a new dental clinic elsewhere. They pointed to an earlier case, Nitza v. Ron (Land Registry Appeal 32926-01-22), in which a dental clinic that did have a valid permit was awarded half a million shekels. In their view, this was not an ordinary home but an active business, which had taken a significant investment to build and would involve special costs to move. They also argued that the other owners and the developer had always known about the clinic, that they had paid municipal tax (arnona) at the business rate, and that the permit was never issued only because of a mistake. They therefore asked that their situation be treated as a special circumstance, and that their compensation be assessed as if the clinic had held a permit.

The Legal Question

When an apartment in a shared building, the largest in the building, has been used for decades as a dental clinic without a permit, are its owners entitled to extra compensation and to the cost of relocating the clinic as part of a TAMA 38/2 project? And does this justify their refusal to join the project?

The Inspector’s Decision

The Inspector rejected the clinic owners’ claims and approved the project without any conditions.

The Inspector ruled that the owners had not proven that running the clinic made their apartment worth more than the others, and that a right to extra compensation cannot be established without evidence. To show that they were being treated unequally, they needed an appraisal comparing their offer with what the other owners were receiving, and no such appraisal was submitted. Even if the municipality knew about the illegal use and charged them business-rate arnona, that did not amount to permission to use the apartment as a clinic, because arnona is charged according to how a property is actually used, not according to what the building permit allows. As for the size of the apartment, the owners again brought no appraisal comparing their expected compensation with that of the other owners, or showing what made their apartment different from the rest of the building. Finally, if running a business without a permit obliged a project to pay for a new, legal business, breaking the law would become a financial advantage. The cost could come out of the other owners’ compensation or threaten the project’s viability, meaning that owners who followed the law would pay the price for a use that was never permitted.

Author’s Note

To the dental clinic owners, their apartment was far more than a home: it was a business built over many years, a financial investment and a source of income. On the face of it, there is a case for giving the clinic extra compensation, under the rule that “equality must be examined by comparing like with like, not parties who are materially different” (Leave to Appeal 5108/23 Eisen v. Bernard). But where the business operates without a permit, and no appraisal shows that the size or nature of the property makes it more valuable, or that there are exceptional circumstances that deserve special consideration, the mere existence of the business does not justify loading extra costs onto the project. A unique business is no substitute for legal and appraisal proof of a right to extra compensation, and it certainly does not retroactively make legal a use that broke the law.

That said, the ruling does not close the door in every case. The Inspector recognized that an exception may be possible where the owners acted in good faith regarding the missing permit, and there are exceptional circumstances that justify special consideration, provided these are backed by a proper appraisal.

(Rehovot 7/25 Halperin Levi Sima v. Yodev Nachum).

(Edited by Adv. Yehonatan Hayat, published 17.11.2026).

The contents of this article are designed to provide the reader with general information and not to serve as legal or other professional advice for a particular transaction. Readers are advised to obtain advice from qualified professionals prior to entering into any transaction.

Share This